Phenomenal concepts and the explanatory gap
WebSep 1, 2024 · While the phenomenal concept strategy is arguably the only response to the explanatory gap that has the potential to be consistent with the science of consciousness, many of its advocates argue that phenomenal concepts may be too opaque to support a legitimate science of consciousness. 8 Philosopher and cognitive scientist Peter … WebDec 20, 2024 · Chalmers, D. (2007) ‘ Phenomenal Concepts and the Explanatory Gap ’. In Alter, T. and Walter, S. (eds.), Phenomenal Concepts and Phenomenal Knowledge (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 167 –94.CrossRef Google Scholar
Phenomenal concepts and the explanatory gap
Did you know?
WebJan 1, 2015 · concepts and the explanatory gap.” In phenomenal concepts and phenomenal knowledge: new essays on . consciousness and physicalism. Edited by torin alter and sven walter, 167-194. Oxford, uk: oxford WebPhenomenal Concepts and the Explanatory Gap. D. Chalmers. Published 2006. Philosophy. Confronted with the apparent explanatory gap between physical processes and …
WebFor example, Joseph Levine, who formulated the notion of the explanatory gap (see above), states: "The explanatory gap argument doesn't demonstrate a gap in nature, ... which argues the difference stems from our inaccurate phenomenal concepts (i.e., how we think about consciousness), ... WebAug 20, 1997 · The explanatory gap derives from the special character of phenomenal concepts. These concepts mislead us into thinking that the gap is deeper and more …
WebPhenomenal Concepts and the Explanatory Gap (2006) This paper discusses materialist attempts (by e.g. Hill, Loar, Papineau, Tye, and others) to appeal to phenomenal concepts to explain away the explanatory gap and other epistemic gaps. I argue that no such account can work: either the account does not explain the epistemic gap, or the relevant ... WebPhenomenal Consciousness: The Explantory Gap 709 phenomenal states.4 This temptation is one that a physicalist (or function-alist) should resist, however, even though it is certainly true that we do often conceive of our phenomenal states in a manner that brings to bear indexicals as well as phenomenal concepts.
WebPhenomenal Concepts and the Explanatory Gap. (2005). Two-Dimensional Semantics. (2005). Perception and the Fall from Eden (2004). Soames on Two-Dimensionalism. (2004). How Can We Construct a Science of Consciousness? (2003). The Representational Character of Experience. (2003). The Matrix as Metaphysics. (2003). Phenomenal …
WebOct 31, 2008 · Phenomenal Concepts and Phenomenal Knowledge New Essays on Consciousness and Physicalism Torin Alter and Sven Walter Philosophy of Mind. Contains … ged cost in texasWebphenomenal concepts can explain the facts that the anti-physicalist claims can only be explained by a non-reductive account of phenome-nal consciousness. Chalmers (2006) argues that the phenomenal con- ... there is an explanatory gap, and that zombies and invertsareconceiv-able. Physicalists deny the next step in the anti-physicalist argument, dbs parcel trackingWebApr 22, 2014 · 2. The Explanatory gap Three decades ago, in a now classic paper, Joseph Levine (1983) introduced the so-called “explanatory gap†in order to name the difficulties materialist metaphysics like physicalism encounter when facing the qualitative aspect of mental states. The thing that made his paper the more important is that Levine ... dbs parkinson\u0027s diseaseWebExplanatory gap Colin McGinn (1995) has argued that given the inherently spatial nature of both our human perceptual concepts and the scientific concepts we derive from them, we humans are not conceptually suited for understanding the nature of the psychophysical link. dbs or pvg checkWebOther proponents of the phenomenal concept strategy include Sturgeon ( 1994 ), who proposes that the explanatory gap is grounded in the fact that phenomenal states serve … ged co to jestWebPenultimate Draft. Final version forthcoming in Philosophical Psychology 6 Regarding the explanation of Mary’s new knowledge, the PCS claims that (most) phenomenal concepts … ged course for freeWebPhenomenal concepts, like proper names, refer directly, and for this reason mind‐brain identities similarly raise no explanatory question. Let us suppose, for the sake of the argument, that we find out that pain is the firing of nociceptive‐specific neurons in … ged course outline